Text原文 Notes注释 Analysis点评 Cases战例 Tool工具
拾贰 12 / 13

火攻篇 ATTACK BY FIRE Attack by Fire · Asymmetric Leverage 火攻篇 · 非对称杠杆 Also: "The Fire Attack" — using elemental force as a strategic multiplier 又名「火攻」——以自然之力为战略倍增器

" 以火佐攻者明,以水佐攻者强。 He who uses fire to assist his attack shows brilliance; he who uses water shows strength. "
Strategic Weight战略权重
65%

SOURCE TEXT & TRANSLATIONS原文与双译

Classical Chinese · Modern Chinese · English古文 · 今译 · 英译

Classical Chinese 原文古文原文

孫子曰:凡火攻有五:一曰火人,二曰火積,三曰火輜,四曰火庫,五曰火隊。 sūn zǐ yuē: fán huǒ gōng yǒu wǔ: yī yuē huǒ rén, èr yuē huǒ jī, sān yuē huǒ zī, sì yuē huǒ kù, wǔ yuē huǒ duì.
行火必有因,煙火必素具。發火有時,起火有日。時者,天之燥也;日者,月在箕、壁、翼、軫也。凡此四宿者,風起之日也。 xíng huǒ bì yǒu yīn, yān huǒ bì sù jù. fā huǒ yǒu shí, qǐ huǒ yǒu rì. shí zhě, tiān zhī zào yě; rì zhě, yuè zài jī, bì, yì, zhěn yě. fán cǐ sì sù zhě, fēng qǐ zhī rì yě.
凡火攻,必因五火之變而應之。火發於內,則早應之於外。火發而其兵靜者,待而勿攻。極其火,可從而從之,不可從而止。 fán huǒ gōng, bì yīn wǔ huǒ zhī biàn ér yìng zhī. huǒ fā yú nèi, zé zǎo yìng zhī yú wài. huǒ fā ér qí bīng jìng zhě, dài ér wù gōng. jí qí huǒ, kě cóng ér cóng zhī, bù kě cóng ér zhǐ.
火可發於外,無待於內,以時發之。火發上風,無攻下風。晝風久,夜風止。 huǒ kě fā yú wài, wú dài yú nèi, yǐ shí fā zhī. huǒ fā shàng fēng, wú gōng xià fēng. zhòu fēng jiǔ, yè fēng zhǐ.
凡軍必知有五火之變,以數守之。故以火佐攻者明,以水佐攻者強。水可以絕,不可以奪。 fán jūn bì zhī yǒu wǔ huǒ zhī biàn, yǐ shù shǒu zhī. gù yǐ huǒ zuǒ gōng zhě míng, yǐ shuǐ zuǒ gōng zhě qiáng. shuǐ kě yǐ jué, bù kě yǐ duó.

Modern Chinese 今译现代汉语译文

孙子说:火攻的方式共有五种:一是焚烧敌军人马,二是焚烧敌军粮草,三是焚烧敌军辎重,四是焚烧敌军仓库,五是焚烧敌军运输队。
实施火攻必须具备一定的条件,发火器材必须平时就准备好。放火要选择有利的时机,起火要选好有利的日期。所谓时机,是指天气干燥;所谓日期,是指月亮运行到箕、壁、翼、轸四个星宿位置的时候。凡是月亮运行到这四个星宿的日子,就是起风的日子。
凡是火攻,必须根据五种火攻方式的变化,灵活部署兵力加以配合。如果从敌营内部放火,就要及早从外部策应。火起之后敌军仍然保持镇静的,就应等待观察,不要急于进攻。等火势烧到最旺时,可以进攻就进攻,不可以进攻就停止。
火也可以从外部放起,不必等待内应,只要时机合适就可以放火。火在上风处放起,不要从下风处进攻。白天风刮得久了,夜晚风就会停止。
凡是军队都必须懂得五种火攻方式的变化,并根据天象气候的规律来防守。所以用火来辅助进攻的,效果显著;用水来辅助进攻的,威力强大。水可以断绝敌人的粮道和增援,但不能夺取敌人的物资和人员。

English Translation

Sun Tzu said: There are five ways of attacking with fire. The first is to burn soldiers in their camp; the second is to burn stores; the third is to burn baggage trains; the fourth is to burn arsenals and magazines; the fifth is to hurl fire among the enemy's ranks.
In order to carry out an attack, we must have means available. The material for raising fire should always be kept in readiness. There is a proper season for attacking with fire, and special days for starting a combustible fire. The proper season is when the weather is very dry; the special days are those when the moon is in the constellations of the Sieve, the Wall, the Wing, or the Cross-bar; for these four are all days of rising wind.
In attacking with fire, one should be prepared to meet five possible developments: (1) When fire breaks out inside the enemy's camp, respond at once with an attack from without. (2) If there is an outbreak of fire, but the enemy's soldiers remain quiet, bide your time and do not attack. (3) When the force of the flames has reached its height, follow it up with an attack, if that is practicable; but if not, stay where you are.
A fire may be started outside the enemy's camp, and there is no need to wait for an opportunity from within — one need only seize the right moment to set it ablaze. One should not attack from the leeward when fire has been started upwind. A wind that rises by day will die down at night.
No army should be ignorant of the five methods of fire attack, and should guard against them by watching for the appropriate signs. Hence those who use fire to assist their attacks show intelligence; those who use water to assist their attacks show strength. Water may cut off the enemy's communications, but it cannot deprive him of his stores or men.

ANNOTATED COMMENTARY逐段注释

Lexical · Institutional · Philosophical字词注 · 典章注 · 义理注

火人
huǒ rén
Burning soldiers — attack on personnel

Literally "to fire people" — the most direct form of fire attack, targeting enemy soldiers and their mounts in camp. This is the highest-impact fire method (weight 0.30) because it destroys irreplaceable human capital and morale simultaneously. Zhou Yu's fire attack at Red Cliffs is the canonical example.字面义"焚烧人马"——最直接的火攻方式,目标为敌军人马。此为五火之首(权重0.30),因同时消灭不可再生的人力资本和打击士气。赤壁之战周瑜火攻即为典范。

火积
huǒ jī
Burning provisions — attack on supplies

Attacking grain stores and food supplies. In pre-modern warfare, logistics determined survival — an army without food cannot fight regardless of numbers. The ancient saying "兵马未动,粮草先行" (soldiers move only after provisions) captures this dependency. Burning supplies strikes at the enemy's most fundamental sustenance.焚烧粮草。古代战争中后勤决定存亡——无粮之军纵有百万亦不能战。古语"兵马未动,粮草先行"即此理。焚粮乃断敌根本。

火辎
huǒ zī
Burning baggage — attack on transport

Targeting the baggage train — weapons, equipment, tents, and materiel in transit. Unlike supplies (火积) which are stationary, 辎 refers to mobile equipment columns. Destroying transport cripples an army's ability to project power beyond its current position.焚烧运输队——武器、装备、帐篷等在途物资。不同于火积(固定物资),辎指移动中的装备纵队。摧毁运输使敌军丧失机动力。

火库
huǒ kù
Burning depots — attack on storage

Striking at arsenals and warehouses — permanent storage facilities for weapons, armor, and reserves. Unlike 火积 (food supplies) and 火辎 (moving equipment), 库 represents strategic reserves. Its destruction eliminates the enemy's ability to sustain a prolonged campaign.焚烧武库和仓库——武器、铠甲、储备的永久储存设施。不同于火积(粮草)和火辎(运输装备),库代表战略储备。摧毁库即断敌持久战之能。

火队
huǒ duì
Burning formations — attack on troop formations

Launching fire directly into enemy battle formations. "队" (duì) here means formation ranks, not modern "team." This is the most tactical and immediate form of fire attack — causing panic, breaking formation integrity, and creating openings for assault. The lowest weight (0.10) reflects its short-term, tactical nature versus the strategic impact of other methods.将火直接投入敌军阵列。"队"指阵形队列,非今义"团队"。此为最具战术性的火攻——引发恐慌、破坏队形、制造突击缺口。权重最低(0.10)因其短期战术性,不如其他方式的战略影响。

因五火之變而應之
yīn wǔ huǒ zhī biàn ér yìng zhī
Respond flexibly to the five fire developments

The core tactical principle of the chapter: fire is not a standalone weapon but a force multiplier that requires adaptive response. "变" (change/variation) is the key word — each fire method produces different secondary effects, and the commander must read these effects in real time and adjust accordingly. This is the opposite of a rigid formula; it demands situational awareness and improvisation.本章核心战术原则:火非独立武器,而是需要灵活配合的倍增力。"变"是关键词——每种火法产生不同次生效果,指挥官须实时研判并相应调整。这与刻板公式相反,要求态势感知与即兴应变。

古代火攻技术与准备
gǔdài huǒ gōng jìshù yǔ zhǔnbèi
Ancient Fire Attack Techniques and Preparations

"烟火必素具" — fire attack materials had to be prepared in advance. Ancient Chinese armies carried specialized incendiary devices: fire arrows (火箭) wrapped in oil-soaked cloth, fire pots (火罐) filled with combustible mixtures, and signal fires (烽火). The logistics of fire attack required dedicated quartermaster units to maintain stores of sulfur, saltpeter, rosin, and oil. Siege warfare frequently relied on fire carts (火车) — wheeled platforms pushed toward enemy gates. This institutional preparation distinguishes professional armies from improvised forces."烟火必素具"——火攻器材须平时备齐。古代中国军队携带专用燃烧装置:裹油布的火箭、装可燃物的火罐、烽火信号。火攻后勤需要专门军需官维护硫磺、硝石、松香、油料储备。攻城战常用火车——推向敌门的轮式平台。这种制度化准备区分了专业军队与临时武装。

天文气象与火攻时机
tiānwén qìxiàng yǔ huǒ gōng shíjī
Astro-Meteorology and Fire Attack Timing

"月在箕、壁、翼、轸" — Sun Tzu identifies four lunar lodges (二十八宿中的四宿) associated with wind patterns. The Sieve (箕), Wall (壁), Wing (翼), and Cross-bar (轸) constellations were ancient Chinese astronomical markers used to predict weather. This reflects the integration of astronomical observation into military planning — a practice that continued through Chinese military history. The statement "昼风久,夜风止" (daytime wind persists, nighttime wind dies) is a practical meteorological observation about diurnal wind patterns that remains broadly accurate."月在箕、壁、翼、轸"——孙武指出二十八宿中与风象相关的四个星宿。箕、壁、翼、轸是古代中国用于气象预测的天文标记。这反映了天文观测融入军事规划的传统——贯穿中国军事史。"昼风久,夜风止"是对昼夜风场变化的实用气象观察,至今大体成立。

曹操注 (Cáo Cāo, 155–220 CE)
「以火攻人,当择时日也。」
"When attacking with fire, one must choose the right time and day." Cao Cao emphasizes timing as the critical variable — fire is a force of nature that cannot be controlled, only channeled. His terse comment reflects his practical military experience as the architect of the Wei state's military campaigns.曹操强调时机是关键变量——火乃自然之力,不可控制,只能引导。其简洁注释反映了他作为魏国军事统帅的实战经验。
杜牧注 (Dù Mù, 803–852 CE)
「火攻之法,先须知敌之虚实。虚则攻之,实则备之。以火为佐,非独恃火也。」
"The method of fire attack requires first knowing the enemy's strengths and weaknesses. Attack when they are weak; prepare defenses when they are strong. Using fire as assistance does not mean relying solely on fire." Du Mu makes the crucial point that fire is a supplement (佐), not a primary strategy — it amplifies existing advantages rather than creating them from nothing.杜牧的关键观点:火是辅助(佐),非根本战略——它放大已有优势,而非无中生有。
张预注 (Zhāng Yù, Song dynasty)
「以火佐攻者明,言用火攻人者,其功最明;以水佐攻者强,言用水攻人者,其势最强。然水可以绝敌之粮道,不可以夺敌之士卒也。」
"'He who uses fire shows brilliance' — meaning the results of fire attack are most dramatic. 'He who uses water shows strength' — meaning the force of water attack is most powerful. But water can cut off the enemy's supply routes without being able to seize their soldiers." Zhang Yu's commentary reveals the asymmetry between fire and water: fire destroys; water isolates. Each has different strategic applications.张预揭示了火与水的不对称性:火主摧毁,水主隔绝。各有不同战略用途。

STRATEGIC ANALYSIS现代战略点评

Eastern Wisdom · Western Dialogue东方战略 · 西方对话

EASTERN ANALYSIS东方战略学

Chapter 12 is the foundation of asymmetric warfare theory in Chinese strategic thought. Its core principles:第十二篇是中国战略思想中非对称战争理论的基石。核心原则:

非对称战争理论Asymmetric Warfare
Fire is the original "asymmetric weapon" — a small force (arsonist) can devastate a much larger force (army camp). Sun Tzu recognized that the lever matters more than the weight. 火是最早的"非对称武器"——小股力量(纵火者)可摧毁大军(军营)。孙武认识到杠杆重量更重要。

资源杠杆Resource Leverage
The five fire methods represent a systematic framework for resource destruction: Personnel → Provisions → Equipment → Depots → Formations. Each targets a different resource tier, from human capital (irreplaceable) to tactical formations (replaceable). 五火法代表资源摧毁的系统框架:人→粮→辎→库→队。各击不同资源层级,从人力资本(不可替代)到战术队列(可替代)。

黑天鹅事件的利用Black Swan Exploitation
Fire, like a Black Swan event, is disproportionate in impact relative to its trigger. A single spark can destroy an empire's war effort. Sun Tzu's genius is in systematizing the Black Swan — turning chaos from unpredictable to weaponizable. 火如同黑天鹅事件,影响与触发因素不成比例。一星之火可毁一国之军。孙武的天才在于将黑天鹅系统化——将混沌从不可预测变为可武器化。

WESTERN DIALOGUE

Nassim Taleb's Black Swan — Taleb argues that rare, high-impact events dominate history. Chapter 12 is essentially a manual for engineering Black Swan events against the enemy: fire is the catalyst that turns normal conditions into catastrophic ones. The key insight: "以数守之" (guard with calculation) — you must predict and prepare for Black Swans while inflicting them on your enemy.塔勒布的黑天鹅理论——塔勒布认为稀有高冲击事件主导历史。第十二篇本质上是制造敌人黑天鹅的手册:火是将常态催化为灾难的催化剂。核心洞见:"以数守之"——你要预测和防备黑天鹅,同时施加于敌。

John Warden's Five Rings — Warden's concentric model of enemy centers of gravity (leadership → key production → infrastructure → population → fielded forces) structurally parallels Sun Tzu's five fire methods. Both identify layered targets from strategic to tactical.沃登五环理论——沃登的敌方重心同心环模型(领导层→关键生产→基础设施→人口→野战部队)在结构上与五火法平行。两者均识别从战略到战术的分层目标。

Edward Luttwak's Strategy Paradox — "The logical extreme of a good strategy is its own negation." Sun Tzu anticipates this: fire attack, if overused or relied upon exclusively, becomes predictable. Hence "以数守之" — guard against the very weapon you wield.卢特瓦克的战略悖论——"好战略的逻辑极端就是否定自身。"孙武预见了这一点:火攻若过度依赖或单一使用,便变得可预测。故"以数守之"——提防你所使用的武器。

火队 FORMATION 火库 DEPOTS 火辎 BAGGAGE 火积 PROVISIONS 火人 PERSONNEL —— Five Fire Methods: Impact Rings ——

CASE STUDIES战例库

Ancient China · Modern Warfare · Modern Business古战 · 现代战争 · 现代商战

attack by fire
Case Study
ANCIENT CHINA

赤壁之战:火攻的极致演绎

Battle of Red Cliffs (208 CE): The Supreme Fire Attack
火人
PERSONNEL
Massive casualties from fire + drowning; fleet destroyed火烧加溺毙伤亡惨重;舰队覆灭
火积
PROVISIONS
Supply lines across Yangtze severed长江补给线切断
火辎
BAGGAGE
All naval equipment and ships lost全部水军装备与船只丧失
火库
DEPOTS
Land-based stores exposed after fleet loss舰队覆灭后岸上仓库暴露
火队
FORMATION
Chain-ship formation amplified fire spread连锁战船加速火势蔓延

Key lesson: Zhou Yu exploited Cao Cao's own tactical decision (chaining ships for stability) as the vulnerability for fire attack. The enemy's strength became his greatest weakness — "因利而制權" (adapt advantage into authority) from Chapter 1.核心教训:周瑜利用曹操自身的战术决策(锁链稳船)作为火攻的突破口。敌之长处反成最大弱点——即第一篇"因利而制权"。

attack by fire2
MODERN WARFARE

东京大轰炸:现代火攻的战略逻辑

Tokyo Firebombing (1945): Modern Fire Attack Logic
火人
PERSONNEL
~100,000 killed in single raid; worker morale shattered单次空袭约10万人死亡;工人士气崩溃
火积
PROVISIONS
Food distribution networks destroyed食品分配网络被摧毁
火辎
BAGGAGE
Transport infrastructure incinerated运输基础设施焚毁
火库
DEPOTS
Factories and warehouses targeted工厂和仓库成为目标
火队
FORMATION
Civilian "formation" — urban density as vulnerability平民"队列"——城市密度成为弱点

Key lesson: LeMay weaponized Japan's urban architecture (wooden buildings, dense population) — the same way Zhou Yu weaponized Cao Cao's chain-linked ships. The principle "因五火之變而應之" (adapt to the variations) guided LeMay's shift from high-altitude precision bombing to low-altitude area incendiary attacks.核心教训:李梅将日本城市建筑结构(木制房屋、密集人口)武器化——与周瑜利用曹操连锁战船如出一辙。"因五火之变而应之"的原则指导李梅从高空精确轰炸转为低空区域燃烧弹攻击。

MODERN BUSINESS

比特币挖矿能源战:新时代的"火"

Bitcoin Mining Energy War: The New "Fire"

In the cryptocurrency world, energy is the new "fire" — the elemental force that determines who controls the blockchain. Hash rate wars (算力战争) between Bitcoin mining pools are modern fire attacks: competitors deploy massive energy resources to "burn" rival miners out of profitability. The 2021 China mining ban triggered a global hashrate migration, demonstrating how energy policy functions as fire attack at geopolitical scale.在加密货币世界,能源是新的"火"——决定谁掌控区块链的原始力量。比特币矿池之间的算力战争是现代火攻:竞争者部署大量能源资源,将对手矿工"烧"出盈利线。2021年中国挖矿禁令引发全球算力大迁徙,展示了能源政策如何在地缘政治层面发挥火攻作用。

火人
PERSONNEL
Miners forced to relocate or quit; talent drain矿工被迫迁移或退出;人才流失
火积
PROVISIONS
Cheap electricity access destroyed廉价电力资源被摧毁
火辎
BAGGAGE
ASIC hardware stranded, sold at loss矿机设备滞留,亏本出售
火库
DEPOTS
Mining farms demolished or seized矿场被拆除或查封
火队
FORMATION
Mining pool hashrate formations disrupted矿池算力阵型被打乱

Key lesson: "以火佐攻者明" — those who controlled the cheapest energy sources (hydro in Sichuan, gas in Texas, geothermal in Iceland) controlled the blockchain. Energy as "fire" follows the same asymmetric logic: a regulatory decree (spark) destroyed billions in mining infrastructure (conflagration).核心教训:"以火佐攻者明"——掌控最廉价能源者(四川水电、德州天然气、冰岛地热)掌控区块链。能源作为"火"遵循相同非对称逻辑:一纸监管法令(火星)摧毁数十亿矿场设施(燎原)。

FIVE FIRE METHODS ASSESSMENT火攻五法评估

Assess your fire attack capability across five dimensions从五个维度评估你的火攻能力

attack by fire
火人HUǑ RÉN
Personnel — attack on people & morale火人——攻击人员与士气
7
火积HUǑ JĪ
Provisions — attack on supplies & logistics火积——攻击粮草与后勤
6
火辎HUǑ ZĪ
Baggage — attack on equipment transport火辎——攻击装备运输
5
火库HUǑ KÙ
Depots — attack on storage & reserves火库——攻击仓库与储备
8
火队HUǑ DUÌ
Formation — attack on troop formations火队——攻击军阵队形
4
7
火人
6
火积
5
火辎
8
火库
4
火队
OVERALL FIRE IMPACT 火攻总评火攻总评 OVERALL FIRE IMPACT
62%
B
Moderate fire capability. Strengthen Formation (火队) attacks to maximize tactical disruption. 火攻能力中等。加强火队维度以最大化战术破坏效果。
Chapter 11 — Nine Grounds第十一篇:九地篇 Back to Index返回目录 Chapter 13 — Use of Spies第十三篇:用间篇